Now I see the flaw in your thinking!
As it's NOT a tradeoff that many are willing to make. And unless you can get 75% of the states to agree it's just not going to happen. What part of "Shall not be infringed" are you having trouble understanding?
I accept the risks, but maybe I'm just old school because I also accept personal responsibility. I prefer to have the security of my family and myself under my control and not that of others.