PDA

View Full Version : Trip Report Subway Bivy



lisa
08-24-2012, 12:19 PM
It was about 7 pm when huge raindrops fell on us in Subway Canyon in Zion National Park. When we felt the rain we were hiking in a smooth, sculpted rock hallway dotted with small pools of water. We had heard thunder throughout the day, and with each clap we looked at each other with wide eyes knowing a flash flood could be coming from the canyons high above us.

Rain equals danger, and the feel of the rain on our skin triggered a rush of adrenaline. This adrenaline drove our 8 person canyon team to desperately claw our way out of the rock hallway, pushing each others butts and grabbing each others arms to get everyone up a short, steep section of rock. Once at the top of that rock we grabbed braches, roots, fallen trees and anything we could use as a makeshift handline to haul ourselves up a steep dirt slope and to the base of a rocky cliff face about 100 feet above the canyon floor. Once at the base of the cliff, we felt safe. We started to catch our breath. The rain continued. What's our next move? There's no flood. The canyon isn't even flowing. The rain is trickling between each grain of sand, saturating the desert, increasing in volume, waiting to rush violently through the canyon in approximately 60 minutes. There was no way to know this, looking down into the rocky hallway from our safe perch above. It looked just as it had when we clawed our way up the slope, mostly dry with just a few innocent pools.

We were aware of the flash flood danger all around us. With each loud clap of thunder we would look at the sky as we approached Subway Canyon via Russel Gulch. In these desert canyons, storms can be life threatening. The rain from a desert storm can funnel into a slot canyon and shoot through like a firehose, tossing a canyoneer around in a rushing soup of large trees, chocolate colored water and boulders. It's a terrifying thought that danced in our minds each time we heard the thunder and looked up at the faraway clouds in the blue sky. We continued down Russell Gulch, pointing out dirt slopes on each side of the canyon we could climb to safety. At each rappel we wondered if we should continue. Russel Gulch is wide and open at most points so escape would be possible in the event of a flash flood, that is, as long as our feet were planted firmly on the ground when the flood threatened and we were able to run to higher ground. The thought of dangling on rappel on one of the three 100 foot rappels in Russel Gulch as the flood rumbled down the canyon was a scary thought I tried not to dwell on too much. I rappelled each drop quickly.

As we neared the end of Russel Gulch and reached the beginning of Subway it was about 4 pm. We had gotten a late start that morning. Our group had driven through the night from Boise, Idaho to use our coveted Subway permit that Friday. We were short on sleep and this was our first canyon together as a group. We moved slowly, partially because some team members were not super experienced and partially because we are just a hedonistic canyon team. We love taking pictures and we love admiring the beauty around us, moving at a pace one could describe as only marginally faster than molasses.

We were 1/4 mile into Subway when the huge drops of rain began to fall. From our cliffside perch, we felt safe as the rain showered us lightly. We talked about our options, which appeared to be going upcanyon or downcanyon. Upcanyon wasn't an option since the best climbers in the group didn't think it was possible. Downcanyon seemed like a dangerous option. We eventually looked around at our rocky perch and decided it had just enough room for the 8 of us to sleep, and by anchoring the people on each end of the bivy line with ropes and harnesses we could safely snuggle in for the night and hope for better weather in the morning. A couple people were not stoked about the bivy and wanted to continue into Subway, but mostly we were in good spirits. A couple people were excited about it and saw it as an opportunity to spend a night out and come back with an awesome story. We had 5 ladies and 3 guys for our cuddle party and we all chose a spot and discussed our individual cuddling and spooning boundaries. We all decided we were pro spooning and tonight was not a time for shyness.

58033

Between us we had only two emergency blankets that were just big enough to cover all of us. We layered our clothing the best we could, with a wet wetsuit as the base layer and any other clothing we had over the top of the wetsuit. I left my wet wetsuit on and also left my wool socks, neoprene booties and canyoneering boots on all night. I wore my helmet for warmth. I put on my climbing harness and hooked myself into the rope at the end of the bivy to anchor everyone in. I snuggled in to sleep and thought, hey this isn't so bad. It's the best bivy weather ever. It's a mild August night, it had stopped raining, there was almost no breeze, and the sky was
full of stars.

We heard a loud rumbling, 10 times stronger than thunder. The sound sent chills through me and I knew right away what it was. Flash flood. Never had I unhooked myself so quickly from a carabiner! I wanted to see that flood more than anything! I've always wanted to see a flash flood from a safe distance. We all scrambled out of our sleeping positions to look over the edge, but the flood was too far below us and our headlamps just wouldn't cast enough light. The loud, rumbling flood continued for about 5 minutes, then the water in the canyon flowed like a small river for about an hour after that. We layed there listening to the water flowing through the tiny slot, thankful to be roped onto our ledge, cuddled up safely.

58032

Then the laughter started. Call it a happy-to-be-alive reaction or a realization of the sheer ridiculousness of our situation. Giggling was uncontrollable everytime the blanket rustled. The laughter would die down, the blanket would rustle and it would start up again. Finally, we were silent for several minutes and people started to drift off to sleep. Then an owl hooted loudly nearby and we were all roaring with laughter again. This went on for the next hour.

Then it was night. Quiet. Cold. It was the longest night ever. I felt like I didn't sleep at all. I found there was only one position where I could stay warm, with my back cuddled tightly against Audra and my arms hugged around my chest. My hip would scream with pain from hours in one position but as soon as I would move I was cold and soon back to the same position. Sometimes I layed there wide awake and felt jealous of the sleepy sounds around me. Why was everyone sleeping so much more soundly than I was? Turns out in the morning everyone said they had moments like this through the night where they seemed to be the only one awake.

58031

I felt happy to see the light begin to creep into the sky. It was a joyful moment. We all started to move around and slowly get up. We shared our remaining food with each other. We were all reasonably prepared with extra food and clothing. We used a ledge to the side of our sleeping spot as our bathroom. Someone suggested we poop on a rock and then throw it, which seemed like a good idea. Except then the poop flew off the rock when it was thrown and splattered nearby. Our bathroom spot became pretty gross and we were anxious to depart. I set up my rope around a tree as a handline down the steep, loose slope and we descended back into Subway. The canyon looked the same, only now there was an intermittent water line about 5 feet high from where the flood had moved through last night. It was the only evidence of the flash and we commented on it all day long as we visualized how powerful the flood must have been in these narrow corridors.

The sky was clear and the morning light beautiful. We resumed our slightly faster than molasses pace and had a wonderful Subway descent none of us will ever forget. We were short on calories and sleep but it truly didn't matter. We were moving gently through a spectacular canyon...and we were alive.

Brian in SLC
08-24-2012, 12:33 PM
Group cuddle...I kinda like the ratio! Ha ha.

Whew! Great story!

Mountaineer
08-24-2012, 12:36 PM
Smart call, glad you are all safe. I think these small bivy bags are only meant to keep you somewhat dry. I can't sleep in them either.

Some of the newer (expensive) flash lights can really throw a long, bright beam. Would have been great to have one of those that night! Not sure what flash lights you had, but typically I carry a smaller waterproof flashlight which probably would have not been enough to see the flood either.

Great TR, thanks for posting.

canyonguru
08-24-2012, 01:04 PM
I can spot quite a few Noob mistakes that could have been avoided, but i wont go there. Good thing you all made it out and that no one got hurt. Good TR, would have loved to see the water line in a picture you were talking about. Would give us the scale of the Flash. Glad your all safe.

Mountaineer
08-24-2012, 01:22 PM
I can spot quite a few Noob mistakes that could have been avoided, but i wont go there.

I hope you do canyonguru, if it can be done in a positive and respectful way. One of the big reasons I've subscribed to this forum is for education and insight. Canyoneering has risks, and we're all for minimizing them. Granted, we all have our acceptable level of risk. If there is a 20% chance of rain that day, do you go into the canyon?

Deathcricket
08-24-2012, 01:27 PM
Wow what a great TR! Thanks for sharing and glad everyone is ok.

ratagonia
08-24-2012, 02:02 PM
Great story, Lisa. Thanks.

May I suggest - that a Restop should LIVE in your pack (and everyone else's) at all times.

Tom

Iceaxe
08-24-2012, 04:31 PM
Bivy bags are worth their weight in gold when needed.... great story. Thanks for sharing.

Sent using Tapatalk

N0_0NE
08-24-2012, 05:08 PM
Thanks for the TR. Epics make the best memories :)

The only mistake I see is that you must have started late. You didn't even get rained on till 7pm. You should have been done with the subway by then. For whoever wants it, my advice is, "start slot canyons early". Especially in July and August. This gives you the maximum hrs in the day to deal with any problems that might arise and usually gets you out of the canyon before any afternoon thunderstorms.

Slot Machine
08-24-2012, 11:35 PM
THAT is a lot of gear for the Subway. Looks like base camp on Everest, minus the snow.

One of everything from Tom's site? Check.
One of everything from Black Diamond? Check.
Watch? Anybody bring a watch? Bah! :haha:

Also, I'll point out a double standard here:
5 ladies + 3 dudes + rain = a not so forced bivy.
5 dudes + 3 ladies + rain = hiking until a flash flood knocks your legs from underneath you. :haha:

I was ready to be critical... until I saw the grin on the guys's face in photo #1.
Shane, quick, change your beta! This is how the Subway should be done!!

:lol8::lol8::lol8:

Someone PLEASE tell the gal in photo #1 that it is OK to remove your helmet when sleeping. Contrary to popular belief, Tom can't sense when you are in a canyon without a helmet. He won't harass you in your sleep like Freddy Krueger.

58039

Great TR! :2thumbs:

Iceaxe
08-25-2012, 06:46 AM
The only rookie mistake the guys made was not telling the girls spooning in the nude would conserve body heat and keep them warm.

:popcorn:

Sent using Tapatalk

Mountaineer
08-25-2012, 08:55 AM
THAT is...

Loved this insight and reply...:)

Canyonbug
08-25-2012, 10:56 AM
Amen! July and August can have canyons done, they have to be chosen wisely and they usually need a really early start. The only time I have ever been threatened by a flash was during the same time frame and that rain came in late in the day. We knew we were on the last rappel and even though we still had a lot of narrows left, we opted to keep moving and we made the exit before being hit.

Glad everyone made it out fine, no injuries and that you have something to educate others with.

ratagonia
08-25-2012, 12:21 PM
Amen! July and August can have canyons done, they have to be chosen wisely and they usually need a really early start. The only time I have ever been threatened by a flash was during the same time frame and that rain came in late in the day. We knew we were on the last rappel and even though we still had a lot of narrows left, we opted to keep moving and we made the exit before being hit.

Glad everyone made it out fine, no injuries and that you have something to educate others with.

Then again, of canyons to start late in monsoon season, Subway is a good one. Lots of escapes possible.

Also, I want to say :2thumbs: for not having a hair-trigger SAR call-out. Yup, it rained, they had to bivy. Walked out the next day. Official drama = 0.

Tom

ratagonia
08-25-2012, 12:23 PM
Someone PLEASE tell the gal in photo #1 that it is OK to remove your helmet when sleeping. Contrary to popular belief, Tom can't sense when you are in a canyon without a helmet. He won't harass you in your sleep like Freddy Krueger.

Great TR! :2thumbs:

Slot Machine - did you read the piece?



I wore my helmet for warmth.


Helmets are quite warm, at least compared to nothing. And by nothing, I mean especially with a haircut like mine. (Lisa does not suffer from that affliction.)

Yes, a hat is warmer. But if you don't have a hat...

Without a pillow, it can be a lot more comfortable to wear a helmet.

Tom

tanya
08-25-2012, 01:13 PM
You all look so cozy! Wonderful trip report!:nod:

abirken
08-26-2012, 07:03 AM
WOW! Awesome write up and so so so glad you guys made the decision to hunker down.

ststephen
08-26-2012, 08:18 AM
Thanks for the very well done write up, Lisa.

Tom's suggestion about a Restop bag or similar is a good one.

Slot Machine
08-26-2012, 03:24 PM
Slot Machine - did you read the piece?

Tom

No, not really. I just can't pay attention when someone talks about the mule-train-load of gear they bring down the Subway. I think it's silly. I stopped reading just shy of the "helmet for warmth" comment and got distracted by the opportunity to draw a yellow helmet on Freddy Krueger. My bad, you caught me. :2thumbs: I read the rest of the report just now. The poo flinging was pretty funny. Hey look, it that a Baby Ruth floating in Keyhole Falls? :lol8:

Iceaxe
08-26-2012, 03:44 PM
:popcorn:

http://www.bogley.com/forum/attachment.php?attachmentid=58039&d=1345876450

http://www.bogley.com/forum/attachment.php?attachmentid=15950&stc=1&d=1190605289

canyonguru
08-26-2012, 06:18 PM
:roflol:
:popcorn:

http://www.bogley.com/forum/attachment.php?attachmentid=58039&d=1345876450

http://www.bogley.com/forum/attachment.php?attachmentid=15950&stc=1&d=1190605289

marlowequart
08-27-2012, 09:27 AM
Having to poop on a rock and chucking it?? Sounds like a sh*tty time(no pun intended, but intended). Remind me not to go rock hunting in the subway.:haha:
Those restop bags serve a double purpose of keeping dangerous animals and tourists away, definitley a good recomendation.

hank moon
08-27-2012, 10:56 AM
Excellent TR, Lisa - thank you for the entertaining and well-illustrated write-up. :2thumbs:

And...a poo-lore promo for all:


http://www.kathleeninthewoods.net/Kathleen_Meyer_Bestselling_Author/Kathleens_Books_-_Kathleen_Meyer_Bestselling_Author.html

Synopsis



It’s the feisty third edition of How to Shit in the Woods, jam-packed with new information for outdoor enthusiasts of every stripe. Hailed in its first edition as “the most important environmental book of the decade” by Books of the Southwest, and in its second as “the real shit” by the late, great, outdoor photographer Galen Rowell, this bestselling guide is often called the “backpacker’s bible” and has sold more than 2.5 million copies in eight languages. Author Kathleen Meyer continues pioneering the way with her inimitable voice—at once humorous, irreverent, and direct—examining the latest techniques for graceful backcountry elimination, and answering a desperate cry from nature concerning environmental precautions in our ever-shrinking wilds.

World changes come fast and furious, and in the backcountry it is no different. The practice of “packing-it-out,” adopted to protect high use areas and fragile eco-systems, is here to stay. We are now often urged to haul our poop home. Or with increasing frequency, the whole business is mandatory. To assist with all this responsible human waste disposal, Meyer’s new edition features the latest in product innovations, from classy high-tech to inexpensive do-it-yourself. She covers the most current solutions to the health risks of drinking straight from wilderness waterways; presents a raft of natural substitutes for the purist swearing off toilet tissue; and offers a wealth of new recommendations for ladies who must make do without a loo.

This down-to-earth guide has been employed as a training aid for scout troops, outdoor schools, and wilderness programs for inner-city youth; for rangers with the U.S. Forest Service, National Park Service, and Bureau of Land Management; as well as for whitewater rafting guides, backcountry outfitters, and members of the military.

Years of rowing urbanites down whitewater rivers honed Meyer’s squatting skills and assured her she “wasn’t alone in the klutz department.” Her shameless discussion of a once-shameful activity, her erudite examination of its associated vocabulary, and her unapologetic promotion of its colorful vernacular make How to Shit in the Woods essential and vastly entertaining reading for anyone who’s ever paused at the edge of the forest and pondered: “Where do I go to go?”

Kishkumen
08-27-2012, 03:18 PM
I always take a tube tent with me. It is light, warm, waterproof, packs small, inexpensive and makes an instant shelter. Can be used as a bivy, ground cloth or tent. Get this "Rookie" tag off me! :crazy:

ratagonia
08-27-2012, 05:05 PM
:roflol:

I am pleased to see that, even though I am like 100 years old, I still look better than Freddy? Or, at least I hope so!

:moses:

Iceaxe
08-27-2012, 05:46 PM
I am pleased to see that, even though I am like 100 years old, I still look better than Freddy?

Do I hear poll?!?

:roflol: :roflol: :roflol:

accadacca
08-28-2012, 11:36 AM
Great report and good decision. :2thumbs:

chabidiah
08-29-2012, 12:03 AM
There is nothing like seeing that first light after a long sleepless bivy..! Good TR way to use your noggin.